Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies (2019 Reviews)

Newborn Pacifier

A pacifier is a sanity saver to new moms.

If you’re an experienced mom, I’m sure you can recall those days you had to spend lots of time on the nursery glider trying to calm the new addition.

There were those moments your baby cried and you felt like crying too because you had used all the tricks to calm them but nothing seemed to work. You remember?

A pacifier is the easiest magic to calm your angel as a rookie mom.

If you want to wean your baby off breastfeeding but you want them to be calm during the transition phase, then acquiring the best pacifier for breastfed newborns is inevitable.

So, which is the best kind of pacifier for a newborn?

Considerations When Looking for the Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies

Must Be Orthodontic

One thing you may be oblivious about is that some pacifiers may interfere with the development of your baby’s jaws. Orthodontic pacifiers are designed in a such a way that they exercise the baby’s tongue, jaw and palate, while realigning the teeth to promote healthy oral development.

So, make sure the pacifier is labelled as orthodontic before making a final purchasing decision.

Texture of the Nipple

The texture of the nipple should be soft. Your baby may feel uncomfortable and may not feel the oral stimulation they’re looking for if the nipple is hard.  Therefore, make sure the nipple is soft and resembles the texture of a mom’s breast.

Easy to Clean

Because some pacifiers do not hold well, it may collect diet and germs from falling. With time, the baby pacifier will require cleaning since you want to prevent bacteria and microbes from forming.

That’s why you should go for a pacifier that is easy to wash. Pay close attention to the material it’s made of by looking at the manufacturer manual to see if the pacifier is stated as dish washing friendly. The best one should not retain water on the nipple region.

Size of the Pacifier

Pacifiers are designed in different sizes to cater for babies in the different breastfeeding phase. A too big pacifier may feel big for your baby and may cover the nose interfering with their breathing.

Again, a too small size may be uncomfortable for your baby. So, choose a size that is just right for your baby’s face.

Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies in 2019 (Reviews)

1. First Years Gumdrop Newborn Pacifier

For Babies Between 0-3 Months

Meet The First Years pacifier, one of the most popular pacifier you'll find in online stores. Like other best pacifier for breastfed babies, this one is also a one-piece construction, and is available in lots of bright colors that you will definitely love.

This pacifier is made from soft silicon to be comfortable on your baby's mouth, plus it won't get fully in contact with your baby's skin to prevent irritation.

Moms love this pacifier because it is trusted in hospitals, plus it comes in five packs, so you'll always have a clean pack with you.

My favorite part is the texture that helps to maintain the pacifier in your baby's mouth without falling off. That means The First Years pacifier will remain in the baby’s mouth for long and will not be inconvenient to your baby.

This pacifier works well with other pacifier attaches, so I'm confident that The First Years will be an inevitable addition to your newborn.

Designed for babies who are between 0 and 3 months, this package is safe and does not include harmful additions like BPA, phthalates and latex.

Things We Liked

  • It is a one-piece material so it won't fall apart
  • Sturdy and durable material
  • Easy to sanitize

Things We Didn't Like

  • You have to get a bigger size to cater for your baby's growth

2. MAM Pacifier, Newborn Pacifier

Statistically, 94% of parents love MAM pacifiers because of a host of reasons that makes them outstanding.  First off, the nipples are soft to mimic that of a breast for easy acceptance. It grows with the baby and helps in healthy feeding and oral development.

The nipple is also easy and comfortable to latch, plus it is anti- slip at the base of the nipple to keep the pacifier in place, unlike other pacifiers from other brands.

MAM pacifier have undergone a rigorous testing so it is approved as high quality. You’ll also love that the pacifier is available in 4 sizes, with each size customized with its nipple and shield sizes to cater for all babies in different stages. The curved shield keeps the pacifier comfortable on the baby’s head.

You’ll also love the dimpling that helps to keep off irritation of the skin by allowing the pacifier to be at a safe distance from your baby’s face.

This pacifier is small, lightweight and comes with a carrying case for easy mobility and sterilization.

Things We Liked

  • Cleaning is easy with the microwave
  • Carrying case for use on the go
  • Holds well without falling

Things We Didn't Like

  • The nipple may be short to some users

3. NUK Newborn 100% Silicone Orthodontic Pacifier

For Babies Between 0-3 Months

As recommended by the American Academy of Pediatrics, this pacifier is made to be one-piece that is 100% silicon.

The silicon material makes the pacifier to be soft when in contact with the baby's skin. Plus, the orthodontic nipple is designed in such a way that it fits well in the baby's palate stimulating teeth alignment and oral development.

The shield is heart shaped to fit well under the baby's nose without interfering with your baby's breathing to prevent irritation.

This pacifier features a scooped nipple cavity for maximum movement of your baby's tongue and thin neck to reduce pressure around the jaws.

As a parent, this pacifier will calm and soothe your angel better when compared to other pacifiers by NUK. Plus, it is designed with 3 vent holes to allow air circulation around your baby's skin to prevent irritation.

This NUK pacifier is constructed to be safe for your baby and does not include harmful chemicals that would interfere with your baby's breathing.

Things We Liked

  • One-piece design
  • Easy to clean and will not trap any water
  • Does not fall from your baby's mouth

Things We Didn't Like

  • It is only available in small sizes

4. Mam Pacifiers, Newborn Pacifier

For Babies Between 0-2 Months

MAM believes that pacifiers should be designed to meet the needs of a baby to suckle. And that's what these pacifiers are designed to do.

Made by experts and parents, this pacifier is designed to be comfortable, healthy and to grow with your baby. It is orthodontic and features a symmetrical nipple and shield, allowing you to place the pacifier in any direction you want in your baby's mouth without interfering with their oral development.

MAM also believes that any product designed to stay for hours in the baby's mouth should be high in quality and that's how these pacifiers are designed. They are rigorously tested as safe and contain zero lead, BPA, phthalates and BPS.

Parent’s love the silicon nipple because it is soft, plus it flattens when sucked to take the shape of the natural breast.

The curved shield allows the pacifier to be comfortable on the baby's face while the bumps within prevents the pacifier from being fully in contact with the body as this would cause irritation of the baby's face. The large holes allow air to get to the skin to prevent irritation.

I love the external texture that is anti-slip to keep the pacifier in place, so it won't fall from your baby's mouth. Plus, it is available in four sizes with a different combination of nipples and shields designed to cater for different ages as your baby grows.

It is small, light in weight and designed to fit well in newborns who are between 0 and 2 months.

Things We Liked

  • Does not slip from the baby's mouth
  • Comes with a sterilizing case
  • Small and lightweight

Things We Didn't Like

  • Outgrows your baby so you have to buy the next size

5. MAM Pacifiers

For Babies Between 0-6 Months

Meet MAM pacifiers, another best pacifier for breastfed babies.  Designed by parents and medical experts, this pacifier mimics the breast for a natural feel and easy acceptance.

It is designed with anti-slip texture to be comfortable on your baby’s mouth while the curved shield design allows the pacifier to be comfortable when sited on your baby’s face.

You’ll love the symmetrical orthodontic nipple for your baby’s developing mouth, plus the multiple small openings on its surface for easy breathing.

Other outstanding features include the patented bumps that lifts the pacifier slightly from your baby’s face to prevent irritation, the large shield to grow with your baby and the reusable carrying case to keep the pacifier clean on the go by sterilizing it in the microwave included for up to 3 minutes.

Things We Liked

  • Easy to sterilize
  • Patented bumps to prevent irritation
  • Orthodontic nipple

Things We Didn't Like

  • The nipple may trap in some water

6. Evenflo Feeding Pacifier Newborn and Infant Pacifier

For Babies Between O-6 Months

Evenflo Feeding pacifier is expertly designed for newborns and infants who are up to 6 months. In stage 1, this pacifier is designed to promote your baby’s natural tongue position while the Balance Plus Cylinder Pacifier will help your baby self soothe while aiding in healthy sucking skills.

As a mom, you’ll love the cylindrical shape pacifier that mimics the shape a baby makes with the tongue when they’re breastfeeding.

Evenflo is designed to be one-piece with easy grip for easy handling. It is soft and designed with flexible materials to reduce fatigue for your growing baby.

You’ll love that that the pacifier comes in a re-sealable steam sanitization bag, usable for at least 5 times for easy cleaning.

It is safe and does not contain BPA, PVC, polycarbonates and adheres with safety measures as set out by FDA on food grade materials

Things We Liked

  • Soft material
  • Easy to clean with the re-sealable steam sanitization bag
  • Easy-grip handle

Things We Didn't Like

  • Too small after 6 months

When Should I Introduce A Pacifier to My Newborn?

Newborns should be introduced to pacifiers only when they are 4 weeks and above after birth. Any period shorter than this would have a negative implication on your baby’s breastfeeding.

According to research, babies who are introduced to pacifiers less than 4 weeks after birth have a high chance of breastfeeding difficulties and improper latch.

The breastfeeding routine is not properly established within the first 4 weeks and exposing them to pacifier sucking mechanism may lead to their inability to latch properly.

Experts also agree that babies who are introduced to pacifier earlier than the suggested period have a longer breastfeeding phase than those who were introduced at the right age.

At What Age Should you Not Give your Newborn a Pacifier?

Most moms will not breastfeed their baby’s once they attain the age of 2. This should also be the case with pacifiers. Any usage after this affects their oral development.

Continued use of pacifier after the age of two may lead to tooth misalignment and palate underdevelopment when they grow up.

Studies also reveal that babies who continue to use pacifiers after the recommended age are likely to experience speech problems which may translate to high bills if you’d want to seek the expert’s advice in future.

When Should You Get a Pacifier Replacement?

Is the pacifier starting to wear off at some sections? If yes, that’s a red flag. The pacifier is no longer safe for your baby’s mouth and you need to find a replacement.

You should also replace the pacifier if the condition of the nipple is no longer the same as when you bought the pacifier.

However, when looking for a replacement, find a color and design similar to the old one because that’s how babies are programmed: to refuse new versions of pacifiers they’ve never seen.

If possible, have a bunch of pacifiers that your baby has shown some preference. This way, you will always have a replacement to give your baby once the old one is worn out.

Wrapping Up

In our opinion we recommend NUK Newborn as the best pacifier for breastfed newborns. This pacifier is orthodontic so it won’t impede your baby’s oral development and tooth alignment. It is soft and unlike most pacifies in our reviews, this one is easiest to clean and will not retain any water.

All in all, we’ve shortlisted only the best pacifiers for you, those which are recommended by experts and parents. Therefore, we believe that any pacifier you pick from our list will resound with your needs as a breastfeeding mom.