Best Mattress for Graco Pack ‘n Play ( Top 5 Reviews in 2019)

Graco Pack n Play Mattress

The safety, health and comfort of a baby is crucial to every parent. These three factors should come first to any parent who is looking for the best mattress for Graco pack 'n play.

For new Moms, a pack 'n play mattress provides a comfortable spot within the Playard for playtime, tummy time and more. It can also be converted into a changing station or play gym when it’s folded.

Sifting through the immense brands to decide on the best can be daunting and overwhelming. Here, I have selected the best five to make the work a little bit easy for you.

Best Mattress for Graco Pack ‘n Play (2019 Reviews)

1. LA Baby Waterproof Portable Mini/ Crib Mattress

With an overall size of 24”x 38”x2”, this pack n play mattress is designed to snugly fit in standardized playards. It is comfortable in depth and your baby will sleep for long without any discomfort.

The tear resistant mattress is made with a waterproof outer and stain resistant layer so wiping or cleaning up will always be a breeze even in the middle of the night when the baby pees.

One important thing you’ll love about the product is that is comes with a 1-year warranty, plus there are no gaps that would be unsafe for newborns or infants. It also fits well with graco pack n play and crib sheets.

The mattress is foldable to fit in a car trunk for use on the go. It is firm and does not pose a safety issue to newborns and infants. It's non-toxic and constructed with certified JPMA products. Also, it is hypoallergenic and anti-microbial with a dust mite barrier.

Things We Liked

  • Firm but comfortable
  • Affordable price
  • 1-year warranty

Things We Didn’t Like

  • May sag a bit at the center

2. Dream On Me Foam Pack and Play Mattress

Like our first review, this pack and play mattress is designed to fit in playards that are 37.5 inches high, 25.5 inches in width and a height of 3 inches with zero gaps. The foam mattress creates a comfortable and supportive environment for playtime.

On the mattress perimeter are border wires to prevent the mattress from sagging and to retain its freshness through the inbuilt air-flow pockets.

The dream on me mattress is made with a waterproof laminated cover that is stain resistant to prevent any fluid from getting inside as well as preventing the accumulation of odor and growth of mold.

The waterproof cover is anti-bacterial in nature and is easy to clean with mild soap and water. This mattress is firm and resilient, plus it is made with high quality materials that are not allergic to the playing baby.

Another notable feature is the lock-stitched binding to prevent unravelling of edges or creating a safety issue.

Things We Liked

  • Bacterial waterproof cover
  • Cleaning the waterproof cover is easy
  • 30-day warranty

Things We Didn’t Like

  • May be expensive to some users

3. Dream On Me 3” Playard Mattress

This mattress is the most popular amongst moms for a myriad of exceptional reasons. First, it is known to provide a comfortable environment f or playing.

The mattress measures 37.5 inches in length, 25.5 inches in width and a height of 3 inches. And that simply means the mattress will sit well in the four corners of the Playard. The corners of the mattress are similar to the corners of the Playard to fit well with no gaps and zero struggle.

The cover of the Playard mattress is not allergic and contains an anti-bacterial waterproof cover. 

This cover is easy to clean and wipe to prevent the formation of mold and odor. This pack n play mattress is GREEN Gold Certified and does not contain flame retardant chemicals like phthalate or lead. It is best for babies who are up to 3.45 pounds.

Things We Liked

  • Waterproof cover
  • Perfectly fits with zero gap

Things We Didn’t Like

  • May be expensive to some users

4. Milliard Tri-Fold Pack N Play Mattress

Made from high density foam, this mattress is designed to provide a perfect balance between comfort and support for the playing or sleeping baby. It is soft to cushion your baby from bruises when playing or having a short nap and measures 38”x26”x1.5” so it fits well in standardized Playards.

The top cover is water and stain resistant. This high-quality polyester cover is easy to wash so there should be no cause of alarm on maintenance.

Like most pack n play mattresses we’ve reviewed, this one is also foldable, plus it comes with a free carrying bag for use on the go.

One important thing you’ll love is that you don’t need a Playard to use the mattress since you can just use the mattress as a sleeping mat for your toddler by laying it on the floor.

Plus, it is made with safety in mind as the whole mattress is fireproof and made with a fiberglass lining for the safety of your child. This mattress is CertiPUR certified.

Things We Liked

  • Rounded corners to fit well with no gaps
  • Soft but firm comfortable foam
  • Removable washable cover

Things We Didn’t Like

  • The price may be high to some users

5. NapYou Pack n Play Tri-Fold Mattress 

The versatile mattress makes a comfortable changing station, comfy spot for playtime, tummy time, toddler bench and play gym when it’s folded.

Like other Playard mattress, this one measure 37.5”x26”x1.5” to fit in all standardized playards. It does not leave any gap that would pose a security risk to infant or newborn.

The top fabric cover is softly comfortable for prolonged comfortable naps and playtime. This cover is easy to wash plus the whole mattress is safe and does not contain toxic chemicals and flame retardants.

We this product because it's a combination of organic cotton and polyester so it is soft enough and will not hurt the gentle kicks or a baby jumping. The mattress is foldable plus, it comes with a one-handed strapped travelling bag for travelling convenience.

It complies with Consumer Products Safety Commission as well as standards as set out by CertiPUR on durability, environmental protection emission, content and performance.

Things We Liked

  • 100-percent money back guarantee
  • Foldable and portable

Things We Didn’t Like

  • May be expensive to some users

How to Choose the Best Graco Pack ‘n Play Mattress

Size of the Mattress

One important thing to consider is the size of the pack n play mattress. For example, a crib mattress is totally different from a pack n play mattress. A Playard or playpen mattress is short and narrow.

Essentially, a standard Playard mattress should measure around 37 inches in height, 25.5 inches in width and a height of 1.5 inches. A wrong size may lead to a huge financial loss.

The good thing is that you can always return the item although this would be a waste of time that would be spent on other things.

The Material

The best pack n play mattress is made from foam. This material provides the necessary support and comfort for playtime, tummy time and more. A comfortable mattress will cushion the baby’s delicate skin.

The material you chose should also be easy to clean or wipe with mild soap and water. The best mattress is made with a water-resistant cover.

Another important thing to consider is if the material is safe or not. Most materials are anti-bacterial and hypoallergenic. A hypoallergenic mattress is best with babies who are allergic to specific products.

Because most covers are made from vinyl, make sure the composition does not include toxic products such as BPA, phthalate, lead, and other toxic elements. A good pack n play mattress is certified by popular organizations like GREEN Gold, CertiPUR and more.

Weight of the Mattress

One important thing about a Playard is that you can use it on the go. Moving a bulky mattress can be exhausting and that’s why it is important you look for a light in weight mattress. In fact, the best pack n play mattress does not have to be bulky. The best thing to consider is if the mattress is comfortable and supportive.

In terms of weight you can choose between foam vs springs playpen mattress. Foam pack n play mattresses are lightweight and portable. They are also cheap.

Although a coiled spring Playard mattress is durable, it tends to be expensive and bulky hence unsuitable for use on the go. The good thing is that both types are safe and comfortable for your playing baby.

Wrapping Up

In our opinion, Dream On Me 3” Playard Mattress is the best mattress for Graco Pack N Play. Other mattresses are also great; however, we choose this one because it is comfortable, waterproof and light in weight. It also fits well in playards when compared to other mattresses for pack n play. 

There are other mattresses you could choose from however, make sure the mattress is comfortable, supportive, fits well and is easy to wash. The best Graco Pack N Play mattress is light and foldable for use away from home.

  • Updated November 12, 2019
  • Baby

Brilliantman is a baby gear and parenting enthusiast. He's very passionate about babies and his mission is to ensure all babies can live a comfortable and happy life. His intention is help moms and dads identify products that will keep their babies happy, safe and comfortable every single minute.